The ferry is not automatically the cheaper option, and anyone who tells you it always is has not priced a discounted flight lately. What the ferry reliably changes is the shape of the trip: no airport, no checked-bag fees, no liquid limits, and you can bring a cooler and fishing gear without negotiating. Here is how the two compare on the things that actually differ:
| Factor | Ferry | Flight | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fare | Operator advertises from $180–$235 (its own figures disagree) | Varies widely; short-haul deals can undercut the ferry | Depends on your dates |
| Door-to-door time | ~2 h crossing + 2 h check-in = ~4 h | ~45 min flight + airport time both ends | Closer than it looks |
| Baggage | Luggage allowance included in the ticket; coolers and gear travel easily | Checked-bag fees, liquid limits, size rules | Ferry 🎒 |
| Departure point | Port Everglades Terminal 21, Fort Lauderdale | Airport, plus transfer at the Bahamas end | Ferry if you're in Broward |
| If it's cancelled | Next sailing may be days away — one ship covers both routes | Multiple daily alternatives | Flight ✈️ |
What the ferry genuinely gives you
- Bring bulky things: luggage allowance is included in the ticket, and coolers, fishing gear and beach kit travel without airline size and liquid rules.
- No airport at either end: you leave from Port Everglades and arrive in Alice Town or Freeport, usually walking distance or a short golf-cart ride from where you're staying.
- Onboard you can move around: Baleària lists air-conditioned cabins, a bar-café, a duty-free shop and an entertainment system on the Jaume II.
- Pets: the operator advertises pet travel options on selected sailings — worth confirming per date, since it is not offered on every crossing.
And the honest downside: with a single vessel covering both routes and a sailing calendar that changes month to month, the ferry has far less slack than a flight. Build a buffer day before any onward flight home.